Notes

Here you can view all the lovely things people had to say about the featured whiskeys and also view pictures that they have submitted.

Mark Peters

Shaft

Do I like Scotch again?

Derek Glunz

Quotes

Definitely starting to enjoy scotch more. I think this is my selection Aberlour 12. Very smooth and a nice touch of spice

Teryn Glunz

Burnt rubber mixed with stale ashes. Thanks but no thanks. Scotch just ain’t my thing.

Michael Pelletier

Love these when I'm in the mood. Just something about the smokiness that complements a fire in the fireplace on a snowy winter's night.

John McDowell

Worm

As they were developing whiskeys in Islay, I can't help but wonder what option 2 was. I mean, how bad did that drink have to taste for this to be the winner? I don't like this one, but can appreciate it's complexity and some of the flavors- the medicinal taste is a killer though

Josh Mitchell

Full Body

Islay? Fairly strong nose, but thin at first taste. The finish is not for me at all.

Zach Lose

After smelling it I put it in my car’s gas tank and improved my mpg by 3.6 miles around the city!

Erin Kraftchick

Mrs Hef

🤢 just from the smell, I'm guessing scotch. Which I'm not a big fan of. It smells like a dirty, medicinal bandage. Tastes only slightly better. Sorry guys, I just can't with the scotch. I gave it a small sip. Gave the rest to Cory, threw out the glass.

Hallie Knuffman

No can do. Too much campfire.

Mitch Mitchell

WeGo

Very strong finish and throat burn.

Nate Knuffman

Smoky and peaty. Celebrating a Pats loss!

Christian Sito

Rough

Curtis Mulder

Almost certain this is Lagavulin ... which (if it is) deserves a couple of quotes from Ron Swanson (Parks & Rec).\nClear alcohols are for rich women on diets."\n“Never been hungover. After I’ve had too much whiskey, I cook myself a large flank steak, pan-fried in salted butter. I eat that, put on a pair of wet socks and go to sleep.”"

Allan Maule

PPP

Has the peaty iodine taste of an Islay malt. The relative lightness of the smoke makes me guess some kind of young Ardbeg.

Jena Singleton

This ones a hard no for me.

Vern McClendon

Islay all the way baby.

James Hatfield

Hanky

Peaty Islay Goodness!!! This stuff is amazing. Tastes like Ardbeg 10. 9/10

Jack Murphy

Is this diesel fuel?

Mark Peters

Shaft

Really enjoyed the first sip, but it fell off a little as I continued to drink it.

Curtis Mulder

Drinkable. Easy. Sweet and smoky.

Trey Heyward

Pretty good. Smoother and a bit more sweetness which I like.

James Hatfield

Hanky

this is actually pretty complex. From the nose I thought it was bourbon, then tasted like an Irish whiskey. This one is a tough guess. Solid little whiskey. 6/10. Watch this be Japanese or Indian. Sheesh.

Derek Glunz

Quotes

Too sweet and some sort of aftertaste, hope this wasn’t my pick

Michael Pelletier

Tasty.

Prev Next