Notes

Here you can view all the lovely things people had to say about the featured whiskeys and also view pictures that they have submitted.

James Hatfield

Hanky

Nothing wrong with this. Yummy hot sugar.

Wil Saleeby

In the words of Cousin Eddie, "Gooo-oood!"

John McDowell

Worm

Nose started good enough...but the wheels came off. Slightly higher proof, but tastes like a 'nice' whiskey someone gave you as a gift because the guy at the store said it was good, but you just end up using it with mixers.

Nick Stone

Clean, hot and grassy. Wintergreen. Tobacco.

Jim Brown

Super sweet on the tongue, but goes away almost instantly. Rye maybe? Not my jam.

Allan Maule

PPP

Sweet start with a spicy finish. I’m guessing a bourbon with high rye bill in the mash.

Quinn Saleeby

This is a daily sipper for me. Typical bourbon flavors

Mark Peters

Shaft

First sip was amazing, but then I really didn't like it. Got worse as I drank it. Cleaning solution aftertaste makes me feel like this is an "Other".

James Hopkins

Tubs

Decent

Chris Northcutt

Not a fan

Jonathan Cory Kraftchick

Hef

Smells like a unique hard cider. Getting a little more oak and leather on the palate. The finish really lingers. Loving this one.

Curtis Mulder

Scotch is growing on me. Not bad not bad at all. Although Kim said the nose is not unlike mail polish remover.

Teryn Glunz

Getting peat and citrus and white wine on the nose. Pretty dry but a bit too much smoke for my liking. Nice clean finish though.

Hallie Knuffman

All the qualities of Scotch that I know--peaty, smoky, grassy. The nose was a little sour & medicinal for me, loved the front flavor, didn't love the finish. I appreciate the opportunity to keep tasting & learning more about these smoke shows. ;-)

Nate Knuffman

Smells like Scotch. Grassy with smoky finish.

Erin Kraftchick

Mrs Hef

Hhm, scotch but not the worst? I'm just going to say smoke and peat because isn't that always the answer for scotch? Watch this be a decoy and me be completely wrong.

Mitch Mitchell

WeGo

This is a good Scotch. Maybe Balvenie?

Johan Martinez

Apple to nose. Licorice to the taste. I was hoping for a bourbon on my birthday today but I think this has to be a scotch.

Derek Glunz

Quotes

Taste like a blended scotch, not my favorite but it's easy drinking.

John McDowell

Worm

Nose is sweet, but something slightly funky there as well, I can't put my finger on it. Very enjoyable overall. Tasty whiskey, I'll be curious to see what other people describe in the flavor

Scott Beckett

🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 🪣

Green apple and honey on the nose. More green apple and oak and maybe some iodine on the palate? Light peat? Reminds me of Highland Park.

Ben Freeman

Wildcard

Tastes like scotch...but lighter/brighter. Looks exactly like piss. Grass/wheat/spice on the nose. Tastes almost "citrusy" with a texture that stays with you for a while....it could be some North Korean whiskey, but has a smoke and char to it.

Matt Roberson

not a scotch guy but this is pretty smooth, nice flavor. good holiday bev

Wil Saleeby

A little hot on the nose. Nice flavor and finish. Very nice ($$$) but maybe a bit "vanilla?

Prev Next